Kinsley, Time, and the scourge of automatic linking

Print is in trouble these days; everyone’s saying it, most recently Michael Kinsley in Time, so there must be something to it. Kinsley’s piece is a discourse on how some news organizations will survive and prosper in the transition from print to online and others won’t.

Given this context there’s an amusing gaffe in the piece as it’s presented on the Time Web site. At one point in his argument, Kinsley writes, “There is room between the New York Times and myleftarmpit.com for new forms.” I assumed “Myleftarmpit.com” was just some phrase Kinsley invented as a generic put-down for a personal Web site, but there it was on Time.com, highlighted as a link. Gee, maybe it’s real! Some obscure site Kinsley wants us to see?

I clicked on it. Oops — file not found. There is no myleftarmpit.com. But some dumb process in Time’s content-management software recognized the domain name and automatically turned it into a link.

Additional, inadvertent lesson from Kinsley’s piece: When news organizations transition from print to online, they need to pay attention to the links they post. Links aren’t technical window-dressing; they are as or more important than the words around them. They need to be edited, too.

3 Responses to “Kinsley, Time, and the scourge of automatic linking”

  1. John Faughnan Says:

    I was certain that by now some prankster would have regisitered the domain and setup an appropriate spoof site. Alas, the young aren’t what they once were. It’s still unavailable.

  2. Ryan Says:

    Actually, the domain has been purchased, but there’s nothing live at the URL. Too bad. If you do a WHOIS search, you can find out who bought it and follow the trail to an unpromising old site the buyer appears to be responsible for.

  3. lorraine Says:

    Hahaha true! The irony of it.

    PS: I came to your site by Googling leftarmpit.com

Leave a Reply